The Ruckers Forum

Forum » Rugby » General Stuff » Meyer reject All Black comparison
Login to reply
3044 Topic: Meyer reject All Black comparison

Status: Hall Of Fame
Posts: 12006
Meyer reject All Black comparison
November 19, 2012, 15:57:28

RYAN VREDE of keo, in London, reports that Heyneke Meyer says comparisons between the Springboks and All Blacks are ill-formed and unfair, explaining the world champions are far advanced in their development.

The Springboks’ victory over Scotland somewhat polarised opinion. Some lauded an almighty defence performance that restrict their hosts to just one try despite their comprehensive dominance of territory and possession in the second half. Other lamented another match in which the Springboks looked impotent, imprecise and unimaginative in what Meyer calls the ‘goal zone’ (between opposition tryline and 22m).

For most the latter group, the All Blacks’ 51-22 victory over the Scots six days earlier was used as the benchmark for the Springboks, and their inability to meet those expectations then fueled their frustration.

Meyer is acutely aware of the criticism and comparison and has generally tried to be diplomatic in explaining the mitigating factors for their struggles. However, speaking in London ahead of the final Test of an unbeaten year-end tour against England, Meyer’s own frustrations were obvious. (Meyer you need the patience of a saint to deal with the ignoramuses! Hahahahahahah) 

Comparisons are always fun to do. Let’s do another one,’ he began. ‘They’ve played Australia, who are one of the better defensive sides in the world and scored three times. We scored five in one match against Australia at Loftus and one in the other [in Perth], so we’ve got six against their three in a game less. Suddenly the picture looks different. (Hahahhahahahahahahahahaha)

They have the luxury of playing a different side if they choose because they’ve developed the depth. There’s more than 19 players either injured, unavailable or retired from the World Cup Springboks (meyer I ahve tried to explain this to the oaks here butthey cant count up to more than five!1 Bwahahahahhahahahahahaha). They use their whole system to ensure the side peaks at the rights times (No wthere i sNO HOPE of getting the oaks to understand palyer managment!!!!!!!). They are far more experienced – with Richie McCaw there as 100 plus games as an assistant and Steven Hansen 100 games an assistant. So you have to compare apples with apples.’

Meyer, however, tempered that stern rebuttal by acknowledging the Blacks’ killer instinct when presented with scoring opportunities, which is a glaring deficiency in the Springboks’ game.

Where they are definitely ahead is that they are far more clinical than us. Whenever they get a chance to score a try they do. Scotland were in the game against them, then they made two errors and the game was different. We were 16-12 up at half time of the Soccer City Test and a mistake from the kick-off and they were away.’

The Springboks’ forwards were awe-inspiring at the gainline on attack in the first half of the Murrayfield Test, as they were in the second against Ireland. Still there is a large degree of predictability about the attack and an apparent lack of spacial awareness of intelligence in contact, which is a hallmark of the Blacks. The New Zealanders carry the ball powerfully, but also possess the presence of mind to do so in a manner that allows them to free their hands often, after which they have the option of picking off support runners, who are never in short supply.

This is the legitimate criticism of the Springboks’ attack, not that they appear to kick away possession (often their opponents, including the Blacks, have kicked more -PLEASENOTE OAKS). It is this refinement that is required and that is entirely a coaching issue.

Well said Meyer but I am afraid your appeals to reason will fall on many a deaf deaf ear. If we run out of gas and lose against england  these bleaters will be all over us like a rash.

Go Bokke one more game!!




Status: Bok regular
Posts: 1396
RE: Meyer reject All Black comparison
November 20, 2012, 08:50:52

the AB kick more but they kick smarter. the boks kicking plan is predictable and easy to read. if the AB are so far ahead in there development then why are we still not employing attacking and skills coaches where our biggest lacking areas are ???


AB ruck skillset is legendary because that is there main focus area and can be trained and learned. in terms of attack HM should leave the overcoach manual at home and allow players to play it as they see it

Leave a reply:

You need to be logged in to leave a reply.

From The Sideline