The Ruckers Forum

Forum » Rugby » Rugby Championship » Bok Player Ratings
Login to reply
 
 
 
2289 Topic: Bok Player Ratings
Username

Status: Bok regular
Posts: 1098
Bok Player Ratings
September 15, 2012, 11:16:31

15.Zane Kirchner (7)
14.Francois Hougaard (6)
13.Jean De Villiers (5)
12.Francois Steyn (8)
11.Bryan Habana (8)
10.Morne Steyn (6)
09.Ruan Pienaar (6)
08.Duane Vermuelen (8)
07.Willem Alberts (6)
06.Francois Louw (8)
05.Juandre Kruger (7)
04.Flip v/d Merwe (7)
03.Jannie du Plessis (7)
02.Andr Strauss (8)
01.Tendai Mtawarira (7)

16.Tiaan Liebenberg (4)
17.Dean Greyling  (0)
18.Andries Bekker (7)
19.Marcell Coetzee ()
20.Johan Goosen (7)
21.Juan de Jongh ()
22.Pat Lambie (4)

There you have it, a win lost via poor kicking at goal and the ref turning on the Boks in the second half. Scum Zealand get another result they do not deserve. 

 


clevermike

Status: Hall Of Fame
Posts: 11937
RE: Bok Player Ratings
September 15, 2012, 14:11:05

Should not react to funny things and try and be serious.

Kirschner - at best 3 or 4 (bad news for reasoins given elsewhere)

Francois Steyn -   6 not equal to Habana

Morne Steyn   -     3  (what about the missed penalties and yellow belly when he passed too early)

Ruaan Pienaar -   5 is the outside limit here

Struass - 6 at best until he improves his line-out throwing

Otherwise  ratings are generally too high for a losing team - most should be one point less than given


clevermike

Status: Hall Of Fame
Posts: 11937
RE: Bok Player Ratings
September 15, 2012, 14:11:12

Should not react to funny things and try and be serious.

Kirschner - at best 3 or 4 (bad news for reasoins given elsewhere)

Francois Steyn -   6 not equal to Habana

Morne Steyn   -     3  (what about the missed penalties and yellow belly when he passed too early)

Ruaan Pienaar -   5 is the outside limit here

Struass - 6 at best until he improves his line-out throwing

Otherwise  ratings are generally too high for a losing team - most should be one point less than given


clevermike

Status: Hall Of Fame
Posts: 11937
RE: Bok Player Ratings
September 15, 2012, 14:11:19

Should not react to funny things and try and be serious.

Kirschner - at best 3 or 4 (bad news for reasoins given elsewhere)

Francois Steyn -   6 not equal to Habana

Morne Steyn   -     3  (what about the missed penalties and yellow belly when he passed too early)

Ruaan Pienaar -   5 is the outside limit here

Struass - 6 at best until he improves his line-out throwing

Otherwise  ratings are generally too high for a losing team - most should be one point less than given


DbDraad

Status: Bok regular
Posts: 865
RE: Bok Player Ratings
September 15, 2012, 16:48:09

Not too bad in general, but you were a bit too generous. Drop all scores by 2.


sasuke uchiha

Status: Rugby Legend
Posts: 5822
RE: Bok Player Ratings
September 15, 2012, 17:15:37

drop morne to 1. he has seriously got no balls, no attacking ability. he only has one trick and thats kicking the ball and today he couldnt even do that,
on the bright side, its time for saffas to embrace the goosen era of rugby, as we all said during the week, i mean like MOST of us said during the week.
morne needs to go, and surely even meyer with his unusual bulls biasdness can no longer deny that goosen should be getting first crack at 10 from now on and lambie to be the fullback.


Saffex

Status: Hall Of Fame
Posts: 8516
RE: Bok Player Ratings
September 15, 2012, 20:35:05

Hougaard is completely wasted on the wing

Morne was nowhere near a 6, give him a 4

Pienaar at best a 5

Jeandre Kruger was not a 7 - 6 would be more like it.

Kirchner was no 7, give him a 6


Leave a reply:

You need to be logged in to leave a reply.
 
 

From The Sideline